What is Alternative Dispute Resolution?

What is Alternative Dispute Resolution?

Introduction

In a world marked by complex relationships and increasing conflicts—whether personal, commercial, or institutional—finding effective, fair, and efficient means to resolve disputes is critical. Traditionally, litigation (court proceedings) has been the go-to approach. However, the Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR) mechanism offers a more flexible, cost-effective, and amicable method of settling conflicts without the need for a full-blown trial.

This article provides an in-depth look at ADR in Nigeria and internationally, exploring its forms, benefits, legal framework, and practical applications. It also features a detailed case study showcasing how ADR can deliver justice while preserving relationships.

Definition of Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR)

Alternative Dispute Resolution refers to a set of dispute resolution mechanisms that function outside the formal courtroom. These include methods like:

• Arbitration

• Mediation

• Conciliation

• Negotiation

• Early Neutral Evaluation

• Collaborative Law

ADR methods focus on dialogue, mutual respect, and creative problem-solving, and are often faster, less formal, and less adversarial than litigation.

Historical Background of ADR

The concept of ADR has deep roots in African traditional societies, where elders and community leaders mediated disputes. In the modern legal system, ADR gained prominence in the late 20th century due to:

• Court congestion

• High litigation costs

• Delays in the justice system

Globally, countries like the United States, United Kingdom, and Singapore have institutionalized ADR, and Nigeria is also making significant strides through various legislation and the establishment of ADR centers.

Forms of Alternative Dispute Resolution

1. Mediation

This is a voluntary, non-binding process where a neutral third party (mediator) facilitates dialogue between disputing parties. The goal is mutual understanding and agreement, not imposing a solution.

Mediation is useful in family disputes, tenancy issues, commercial disagreements, and workplace conflicts.

2. Arbitration

Arbitration is a more formal ADR method where an arbitrator (or panel) hears both sides and renders a decision, which is binding (except where stated otherwise). It resembles court proceedings but is private and more flexible.

It is common in commercial contracts, construction, shipping, and international trade.

3. Conciliation

Similar to mediation, but the conciliator may play a more active role, including suggesting possible solutions. Conciliation is particularly used in labour and employment disputes.

4. Negotiation

This is the simplest form of ADR, where the parties themselves engage in discussions to resolve their dispute without a third party. It is informal, flexible, and confidential.

5. Early Neutral Evaluation

In this process, a neutral expert assesses the facts and legal positions of each side early in the dispute and gives a non-binding opinion on likely outcomes. This helps guide further negotiation or settlement.

Differences Between ADR and Litigation

Legal Framework of ADR in Nigeria

Several laws and bodies regulate ADR in Nigeria:

1. The Constitution of Nigeria (1999 as amended)

Although not explicitly stating ADR, it promotes amicable settlement of disputes under the fundamental objectives.

2. Arbitration and Conciliation Act (Cap A18, LFN 2004)

This Act governs domestic and international arbitration, providing rules, procedures, and enforcement mechanisms.

3. Lagos State Multi-Door Courthouse (LMDC) Law

Pioneered in Lagos State and adopted by others, it institutionalizes ADR as part of the judicial process.

4. High Court Rules

Many courts, like the Lagos and Abuja High Courts, now require Pre-action Protocols or referral to ADR before litigation.

5. Legal Practitioners Rules of Professional Conduct

Encourages lawyers to consider out-of-court settlement before commencing litigation.

Benefits of ADR

• Time-saving: Quicker than traditional litigation.

• Cost-effective: Reduces legal and administrative expenses.

• Confidentiality: Keeps disputes private, protecting reputations.

• Preservation of relationships: Especially important in family and business contexts.

• Flexibility: Procedures are adaptable.

• Expertise: Parties can choose neutral experts in relevant fields.

• Party autonomy: More control over outcomes.

Challenges of ADR in Nigeria

• Limited public awareness

• Lack of trained mediators/arbitrators in some regions

• Weak enforcement mechanisms in rural areas

• Resistance from lawyers preferring litigation

• Cultural and traditional bias against ADR in some settings

ADR Institutions in Nigeria

1. Lagos Multi-Door Courthouse (LMDC)

2. Negotiation and Conflict Management Group (NCMG)

3. Chartered Institute of Arbitrators (UK) Nigeria Branch

4. Regional ADR Centers under NBA

5. Institute of Chartered Mediators and Conciliators (ICMC)

6. Nigerian Communications Commission (NCC) ADR Centre

7. National Industrial Court ADR Centre

ADR and Commercial Disputes

ADR is highly recommended in:

• Construction contracts

• Oil & gas

• Telecommunication

• Banking and finance

• International trade

Many contracts now contain ADR clauses, especially arbitration agreements requiring parties to arbitrate disputes before resorting to court.

ADR in Matrimonial and Family Disputes

Mediation and conciliation are effective in resolving:

• Divorce and separation

• Custody battles

• Inheritance disputes

• Domestic violence (with caution)

Family law courts now recommend ADR to reduce hostility, especially where children are involved.

ADR in Labour and Employment Disputes

The National Industrial Court of Nigeria (NICN) has an ADR Centre for resolving employer-employee conflicts through:

• Mediation

• Arbitration

• Conciliation

The Trade Disputes Act also encourages ADR in resolving industrial actions and collective bargaining issues.

ADR and Court Systems: The Multi-Door Courthouse (MDC)

The Multi-Door Courthouse system integrates litigation and ADR into a single judicial framework. Parties can access different “doors” (mediation, arbitration, conciliation) depending on the nature of their dispute.

Advantages include:

• Early settlement

• Case decongestion

• User-friendly justice delivery

Several states now have Multi-Door Courthouses.

International Recognition of ADR Awards

Arbitral awards made in Nigeria can be enforced in other countries under the New York Convention on Recognition and Enforcement of Foreign Arbitral Awards (1958), which Nigeria ratified.

Similarly, foreign arbitral awards can be enforced in Nigeria under the Arbitration and Conciliation Act.

ADR Clauses in Contracts

Example of an ADR clause:

“In the event of a dispute arising from this Agreement, the parties shall first attempt to resolve the dispute amicably through mediation under the rules of the [Insert ADR Institution]. If mediation fails, the dispute shall be submitted to arbitration in accordance with the Arbitration and Conciliation Act.”

This type of clause is legally binding and enforces party autonomy.

Case Study: Dangote Group v. X Construction Ltd (2020)

Background

The Dangote Group entered into a contract with X Construction Ltd for the building of a multi-billion naira plant. A dispute arose over delayed delivery and alleged breach of contract.

Initial Conflict

X Construction sued for breach at the Federal High Court. Dangote Group filed an application referring the matter to arbitration as stipulated in the contract’s ADR clause.

ADR Process

• The court granted a stay of proceedings pending arbitration.

• A panel of three arbitrators was appointed.

• The hearings were conducted over six months in Lagos and online (due to COVID-19).

• Expert witnesses were invited.

Outcome

The arbitrators issued an award in favor of Dangote Group, but also awarded part-payment to X Construction for completed milestones.

Lessons

• The ADR process saved time and preserved the business relationship.

• Confidentiality protected both parties’ reputation.

• The arbitral award was enforced under the Arbitration and Conciliation Act.

This case highlights the efficiency and power of ADR in handling complex commercial disputes.

Future of ADR in Nigeria

The future of ADR in Nigeria is promising, with:

• Increased court referrals

• Technology integration (e.g., online mediation platforms)

• Public and private sector collaboration

• ADR education in law faculties

• Stronger enforcement mechanisms

Legal practitioners are being urged to embrace ADR as the first step, not the last resort, in dispute resolution.

Conclusion

Alternative Dispute Resolution is not merely a second-best option—it is a transformational tool that brings efficiency, peace, and justice into the realm of conflict resolution. In Nigeria, it is steadily becoming the preferred mode of resolving disputes across multiple sectors.

Whether you’re a businessperson, family head, employer, or individual seeking justice, ADR offers a dignified, less adversarial, and more harmonious pathway

Settle Disputes Peacefully, Professionally, and Privately

Disputes don’t always need to end in court battles. Whether you’re a business owner, professional, or private individual, Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR) offers a faster, more affordable, and confidential path to justice.

At Chaman Law Firm, we help resolve conflicts through Mediation, Arbitration, and Conciliation—saving you time, money, and stress. Our legal team includes certified mediators and arbitrators who are trained to bring lasting peace and win-win outcomes.

📞Phone:  08065553671, 08096888818

✉ Email: chamanlawfirm@gmail.com

📍 Address: 115, Obafemi Awolowo Way, Allen Junction, Ikeja, Lagos, Nigeria

🌍Click here to learn more about Chaman Law Firm

Let’s help you resolve disputes without going to court. Your peace of mind is just a call away.

Chaman Law Firm – Your Right, We Protect.