Mortgage Vis-a-Vis Similar Transactions
Introduction
In Nigeria, a mortgage is a common legal mechanism used by individuals and businesses to secure loans with property. However, other similar transactions such as pledges, charges, liens, and conditional sales are also used as security for financial obligations. These arrangements often appear similar but have significant legal distinctions. This article explores the legal meaning of a mortgage, its creation and enforcement, and how it compares to other security arrangements under Nigerian law. It also includes a practical case study to illustrate these legal concepts.
Meaning and Nature of a Mortgage
A mortgage is a legal transaction in which a borrower (mortgagor) transfers an interest in land or real property to a lender (mortgagee) as security for a loan or other obligation. The main purpose of this transfer is to secure the repayment of the loan. Once the loan is repaid, the interest in the property is re-transferred to the mortgagor. If the borrower defaults, the mortgagee can enforce their rights through sale, possession, or foreclosure.
A mortgage is not an outright sale of property. Instead, it is a temporary transfer of interest with the primary aim of securing repayment. The mortgagor retains a right of redemption, which is the legal right to reclaim full ownership of the property upon fulfilling the terms of the mortgage.
Characteristics of a Mortgage Transaction
A typical mortgage has certain essential features:
Security Interest in Land: The mortgage involves the transfer of an interest in land or property.
Right of Redemption: The borrower has the right to reclaim the property upon repayment.
Registration: Legal mortgages must be registered with the appropriate Land Registry, and where the borrower is a company, at the Corporate Affairs Commission.
Enforceability: If the borrower defaults, the lender can enforce their rights through remedies like sale or foreclosure.
Loan Agreement: The mortgage usually arises from an underlying loan agreement setting out the amount borrowed, interest, and repayment terms.
Types of Mortgage in Nigeria
Mortgages may be classified based on their legal structure:
Legal Mortgage: This is a mortgage created by deed and properly registered. It gives the mortgagee a legal interest in the property and confers power of sale in case of default.
Equitable Mortgage: This is created when a borrower deposits title documents with the lender with an intention to create a security interest, even if a formal deed is not executed. It is not as enforceable as a legal mortgage unless properly documented.
Third-Party Mortgage: Here, a third party offers their property as security for a loan taken by another individual or entity.
All Monies Mortgage: This form of mortgage secures all present and future obligations that a borrower owes to the lender, not just a specific loan.
Key Parties in a Mortgage Transaction
The essential parties in a mortgage transaction include:
Mortgagor: The borrower who owns the property and offers it as security.
Mortgagee: The lender who receives the mortgage as security for the loan.
Solicitors: Legal professionals who prepare, review, and perfect the mortgage documents.
Valuers/Surveyors: Professionals who assess the value of the property being mortgaged.
Procedure for Creating a Legal Mortgage in Nigeria
To create a legally enforceable mortgage in Nigeria, the following steps are typically followed:
Company or Individual Agreement: If the borrower is a company, ensure it has the power to mortgage property in its memorandum of association. If it’s an individual, confirm the legal ownership of the property.
Loan Agreement: A formal agreement is executed between the borrower and lender, detailing the amount borrowed, the interest rate, and repayment schedule.
Search and Due Diligence: The lender conducts a search at the Land Registry to confirm the ownership and status of the property. This also ensures there are no encumbrances or pending charges.
Governor’s Consent: Under the Land Use Act, any transfer of interest in land requires the consent of the Governor of the state where the land is located.
Execution of Deed of Legal Mortgage: The mortgage is created by a formal deed, signed by both parties and witnessed.
Stamp Duty Payment: The mortgage document is taken to the tax office for payment of stamp duties.
Registration at Land Registry: The deed of mortgage is registered with the state’s Land Registry. This provides public notice and makes the mortgage enforceable against third parties.
Perfection: In the case of a corporate borrower, the mortgage must also be registered at the Corporate Affairs Commission.
Legal Effects of a Mortgage
Once created and perfected, a mortgage has the following legal implications:
The mortgagee acquires an enforceable interest in the property.
The mortgagor is barred from dealing with the property in a manner that affects the mortgagee’s rights.
The lender has legal remedies available in the event of default, such as power of sale or foreclosure.
The mortgagor retains the equity of redemption until default occurs or foreclosure is completed.
Any further transaction concerning the mortgaged property requires the consent of the mortgagee.
Meaning and Features of Similar Transactions
Several financial transactions resemble mortgages but differ in form and legal consequence. These include:
Pledge
A pledge occurs when personal property is physically delivered by the borrower (pledgor) to the lender (pledgee) as security for a debt. The lender holds the property until the debt is repaid. If the borrower defaults, the lender may retain the property or seek judicial sale. Pledges apply only to movable property.
Charge
A charge creates a security interest over property without transferring possession or ownership. It may be fixed (attached to specific assets) or floating (covering changing assets like stock). A charge must be documented and registered, especially when created by companies.
Lien
A lien gives a creditor the right to retain possession of the debtor’s property until a debt is paid. It arises by operation of law, such as a mechanic’s lien or banker’s lien. It does not confer a right of sale unless specifically allowed by law or contract.
Sale with Right of Repurchase
This transaction is structured as an outright sale, but the seller retains a right to repurchase the property after a fixed time. Courts may interpret it as an equitable mortgage, especially if the intent was to secure a loan and not an actual sale.
Secured Loan Agreements
Some loans are structured with collateral but without formal conveyance of property. These include agreements backed by personal guarantees, promissory notes, or indemnity undertakings. Although enforceable, they lack the proprietary nature of a mortgage.
Differences Between a Mortgage and Similar Transactions
While mortgages, pledges, charges, liens, and sales with repurchase may serve similar economic functions—securing repayment—they differ in fundamental ways:
A mortgage involves the transfer of a proprietary interest in land, with formal documentation, governor’s consent, and registration.
A pledge is based on physical possession of movable property without title transfer.
A lien arises automatically by law and grants only possessory rights.
A charge creates an equitable interest without physical possession or title transfer, usually over corporate assets.
A sale with repurchase is disguised as a sale but may be judicially interpreted as an equitable mortgage based on intent.
Comparative Legal Analysis of Mortgage Vis-à-Vis Similar Transactions
The mortgage stands out as the most secure and enforceable form of asset-backed loan under Nigerian law. It offers the mortgagee proprietary remedies and legal standing superior to charges or pledges.
While pledges rely on possession and charges on equitable interest, a legal mortgage gives the lender a real, registered legal interest in the borrower’s land or property. Charges and pledges may be faster and less formal, but they carry greater risks in enforcement.
Liens, on the other hand, do not require any agreement and arise automatically in certain professions, but they are limited in scope and do not grant sale rights.
A conditional sale (sale with repurchase) lacks transparency and is prone to disputes unless properly structured. Courts often recharacterize such arrangements as mortgages where loan intention is evident.
Regulatory Framework Governing Mortgages in Nigeria
The following laws and regulations govern mortgage creation and enforcement in Nigeria:
Land Use Act, 1978: Requires Governor’s consent for alienation of land.
Conveyancing Act, 1881 and Property and Conveyancing Law (1959): These statutes regulate the rights and duties of mortgagees and mortgagors in various regions.
Companies and Allied Matters Act (CAMA), 2020: Governs company-created charges and mandates their registration at CAC.
Stamp Duties Act: Regulates the payment of duties on mortgage documents.
High Court Rules: Prescribe procedures for foreclosure, injunctions, and enforcement proceedings.
Mortgage Institutions Act: Governs primary mortgage institutions.
Risks and Legal Implications
Common legal pitfalls include:
Improper Drafting: Failure to clearly define terms and conditions may invalidate the mortgage.
Lack of Governor’s Consent: Renders the transaction void under the Land Use Act.
Failure to Register: Makes the mortgage ineffective against third parties.
Waiver of Right to Redeem: Clauses that seek to deny the mortgagor’s right to redemption are void as being repugnant to equity.
Legal clarity, registration, and compliance with procedure are critical to the enforceability of any mortgage or related security transaction.
Remedies for Breach of Mortgage and Related Transactions
In cases of default, the mortgagee may pursue several remedies:
Foreclosure: This is a court order extinguishing the mortgagor’s right of redemption and transferring absolute title to the mortgagee.
Power of Sale: Many legal mortgages confer the right to sell the property without court intervention, provided notice is given.
Possession: The mortgagee may take possession of the mortgaged property, particularly in commercial property leases.
Appointment of Receiver: Especially in corporate mortgages, a receiver may be appointed to manage the mortgaged asset and apply income to repay the debt.
For pledges, the remedy is to retain or apply to sell the goods. In charges, the lender may seek judicial enforcement or asset freezing.
Case Study: UBA v. Okafor & Sons Ltd (Illustration)
Background
UBA advanced a loan of ₦100 million to Okafor & Sons Ltd, secured by a legal mortgage on the company’s warehouse in Lagos. Additionally, the directors pledged their company vehicles and executed a personal guarantee.
Default and Enforcement
Okafor defaulted on repayment, and UBA issued a demand notice. When no payment was made, UBA exercised its power of sale and auctioned the mortgaged warehouse. It also commenced action in court to sell the pledged vehicles and enforce the directors’ guarantees.
Court Ruling
The court upheld UBA’s right to sell the mortgaged property, citing compliance with the Land Use Act, proper registration, and valid power of sale. For the pledged assets, the court ruled that UBA must obtain a court order before sale, as possession had not been transferred. The personal guarantee was also enforced, with the directors held liable.
Lesson
This case illustrates the superiority of legal mortgages for loan recovery and the need for proper documentation and procedural compliance.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
Q1: Is registration of a mortgage compulsory?
Yes. Legal mortgages must be registered with the Land Registry, and for companies, with the CAC.
Q2: Can a borrower redeem the mortgaged property after default?
Yes, unless the court has issued a foreclosure order, the borrower retains the right to redeem the property.
Q3: What’s the difference between a lien and a pledge?
A lien arises by operation of law and only grants possession, while a pledge is a consensual security involving possession of the asset.
Q4: Can a mortgage be used to secure a future loan?
Yes, through an “all-monies mortgage” clause that covers future indebtedness.
Q5: Must all secured loans involve property?
No. Security can involve movable property (e.g., vehicles) or intangible assets like receivables.
Conclusion
A mortgage remains the most secure and enforceable form of credit security involving land in Nigeria. However, parties must understand the nuances between mortgages and other transactions like pledges, charges, and liens. Proper legal guidance is essential to structure transactions that are valid, enforceable, and protective of both parties’ interests.
While all these transactions aim to secure debt repayment, they differ in structure, risk, enforceability, and legal implications. Therefore, the advice of a property lawyer is indispensable in negotiating, drafting, and executing any such agreement.
Need Help Structuring or Understanding Mortgage and Security Transactions?
Whether you are a lender, borrower, property investor, or legal professional, understanding the differences between mortgages, pledges, charges, liens, and similar transactions is critical to protecting your financial and legal interests.
At Chaman Law Firm, we provide expert legal advisory, documentation, and enforcement support for all types of security arrangements, including:
Drafting and perfection of legal and equitable mortgages
Governor’s consent and land registry registration
Preparation and review of loan agreements, charges, and pledges
Litigation and enforcement of mortgage rights
Legal due diligence and risk advisory for lenders and borrowers
📞Phone: 08065553671, 08096888818
✉ Email: chamanlawfirm@gmail.com
📍 Address: 115, Obafemi Awolowo Way, Allen Junction, Ikeja, Lagos, Nigeria
🌍Click here to learn more about Chaman Law Firm
Avoid costly mistakes. Let legal experts secure your transactions the right way.
Chaman Law Firm — Your Right, We Protect.