Introduction
Tax planning is a legal and ethical approach to managing one’s financial affairs to minimize tax liabilities by utilizing deductions, credits, and exemptions within the framework of the law. This strategy involves making informed decisions to structure financial activities in a manner that reduces tax burdens while fully complying with both the letter and the spirit of tax laws. Tax planning is recognized as an honest and responsible means of applying tax provisions to achieve favorable tax outcomes.
In the case of G. M. Akinsete Syndicate v Senior Inspector of Taxes, Akure, the Supreme Court of Nigeria affirmed that an individual is entitled to use lawful means to reduce tax obligations, provided they do not attempt to evade taxes. This principle echoes the sentiments expressed in the English case of Ayrshire Pullman Motor Services v IRC, where Lord Clyde famously remarked that taxpayers are within their rights to take advantage of legal provisions to minimize tax payments, just as tax authorities are justified in enforcing tax laws to maximize revenue.
Limits of Tax Planning in Nigeria
While tax planning is legally permitted in Nigeria, the law imposes certain limitations to prevent its abuse and ensure that tax planning does not cross the line into tax evasion. Various statutory instruments and regulations, including the General Anti-Avoidance Provisions (GAAPs), Income Tax (Country-by-Country Reporting) Regulations 2018 (CBCR Regulations), Income Tax (Transfer Pricing) Regulations 2018 (TP Regulations), and Income Tax (Common Reporting Standard) Regulations 2019 (CRS Regulations), outline these limits.
The GAAPs are designed to prevent schemes that are primarily intended to avoid taxes. These provisions empower tax authorities to disregard or reclassify transactions that are artificial, fictitious, or lack real commercial value, ensuring that taxpayers cannot exploit loopholes to evade taxes. However, while GAAPs have been effective in the past, they may not fully address the complexities of modern tax planning, particularly in relation to Base Erosion and Profit Shifting (BEPS). BEPS strategies exploit gaps in tax rules across different jurisdictions to shift profits to low or no-tax locations, eroding the tax base in higher-tax countries.
To combat BEPS, the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD) proposed several reforms in its 2015 report, including requiring taxpayers to disclose aggressive tax planning arrangements, making dispute resolution systems more effective, and strengthening rules for controlled foreign companies.
Another key regulation is the Income Tax (Country-by-Country Reporting) Regulations 2018 (CBCR Regulations). These regulations, effective from January 1, 2018, require Multinational Enterprise Groups (MNE Groups) with a Consolidated Group Revenue (CGR) of ₦160 billion or more to submit detailed tax and financial information to the Federal Inland Revenue Service (FIRS). This information includes revenue, income allocation, taxes paid, stated capital, number of employees, and business activities across various tax jurisdictions. Non-compliance with the CBCR Regulations can result in penalties, and any arrangements made primarily to avoid these obligations can be disregarded by the FIRS.
However, the validity of the CBCR Regulations is uncertain, as the Country-by-Country Multilateral Competent Authority Agreement (MCAA), which these regulations aim to enforce, has not yet been domesticated by an Act of the National Assembly, as required by Section 12(1) of the Nigerian Constitution.
Tax Avoidance
Tax avoidance, while legal, involves strategically restructuring one’s financial affairs to minimize tax liabilities. This is achieved through the lawful use of deductions, credits, and other provisions within the tax code. Although tax avoidance is within the bounds of the law, it is often viewed as morally questionable because it seeks to circumvent the spirit of the law. For example, individuals may use tax avoidance techniques to reduce or eliminate liabilities such as Capital Gains Tax, employing what some describe as “lawful tricks” to achieve these outcomes.
Effects of Tax Avoidance on the Economy
1. Inability of the Government to Execute Socio-Economic Programs: When tax revenues are reduced due to avoidance and evasion, the government struggles to fund essential services and infrastructure. This shortfall affects the provision and maintenance of roads, water supply, public schools, healthcare facilities, and the payment of civil servants’ salaries. As a result, the quality of public services declines, and the government faces difficulties in fulfilling its responsibilities.
2. Reduction in Revenue: Tax avoidance and evasion significantly diminish the revenue that the government could otherwise collect. This loss often forces the government to borrow, increasing national debt and potentially leading to economic instability. Additionally, reduced revenue limits the country’s ability to invest in international trade and other economic activities that could boost the economy and strengthen international relations.
3. Stagnancy in Economic Growth and Development: The lack of sufficient tax revenue hampers the country’s economic growth and development. Taxes are crucial for funding projects that improve citizens’ quality of life and enhance the country’s global standing through international trade and alliances. When individuals and businesses avoid or evade taxes, the government cannot effectively invest in these areas, leading to economic stagnation and undermining the nation’s long-term stability.
The enactment of the Finance Act 2020 introduces significant changes to Nigeria’s tax administration, aiming to address some of the challenges posed by tax avoidance and evasion. For instance, the amended Section 49(1) of the Personal Income Tax Act requires individuals and businesses to provide a Tax Identification Number (TIN) as a condition for opening or maintaining business bank accounts. This measure enables the Federal Inland Revenue Service (FIRS) to track taxable persons and reduce tax evasion.
Moreover, the Finance Act 2020 removes certain allowances that were previously abused for fraudulent tax deductions and imposes stricter penalties for non-compliance with tax registration requirements. For example, under the new Section 8 of the Value Added Tax Act, defaulters who fail to register with the FIRS may face fines of ₦50,000 for the first month and ₦25,000 for subsequent months of non-compliance. Additionally, the definition of goods under the Value Added Tax Act has been expanded to include incorporeal properties such as rights, patents, and trademarks, ensuring that these are now subject to VAT.
These legislative changes reflect a broader effort to strengthen Nigeria’s tax system, enhance compliance, and ensure that all taxpayers contribute their fair share to the nation’s development. By balancing the need for legal tax planning with robust enforcement against tax evasion, Nigeria can achieve sustainable economic growth and development.
Conclusion
Tax avoidance and tax planning must be effectively regulated and controlled to ensure the growth and development of any economy. Fortunately, the 2020 Finance Act has addressed many of the loopholes that dubious taxpayers might exploit to minimize their tax liabilities. The laws are now clearly defined, leaving little room for ambiguity, which helps to curb the misuse of tax planning and avoidance strategies.
Contact Us
For premier ways of Legal Aspects of Tax Planning and Tax Avoidance in Nigeria, contact Chaman Law Firm today. Our offices are conveniently located in Lagos, FCT Abuja, Ogun State, and the UK. We are readily available to assist you with your legal needs. Whether you require consultation, representation, or ongoing legal support, Chaman Law Firm is your trusted partner in Aspects of Tax Planning and Tax Avoidance.
Call us at 08065553671 or email us at info@chamanlawfirm.com to schedule a consultation.
- International Tax Planning in Nigeria
- Legal Tax Shelters in Nigeria
- Transfer Pricing Regulations
- Capital Gains Tax Planning
- Double Taxation Treaties in Nigeria
- VAT Planning and Optimization
- Tax Exemptions and Reliefs
- Ethical Tax Avoidance Practices
- Tax Dispute Resolution in Nigeria
- Legal Risks in Tax Avoidance Strategies
Chaman Law Firm: Your Trusted Legal Partner in Legal Aspects of Tax Planning and Tax Avoidance
By choosing Chaman Law Firm, you are selecting a team of dedicated professionals committed to providing exceptional guideline tailored to your unique needs. Let us be your advocate and guide in the complex world of Legal Aspects of Tax Planning and Tax Avoidance in Nigeria, ensuring your interests are protected and your goals are achieved.